« If you check your pulse daily, one day it will flatline | Main | Bad covid data: feature or bug in Texas? »


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Michael Droy

while only deaths that are confirmed with a positive SAR-CoV-2 diagnosis are counted in the denominator (under-counted).

Are they? Excess deaths is partly a function of temporarily inadequate health facilities. And there are certainly cases of "covid present" interpreted as "Covid cause". There may be some undercounting, but not nearly as much as often claimed.

More importantly the forecast all time deaths from Covid keeps on collapsing while the advance towards herd immunity is rapid as we understand more about immunity being a thing for large proportions of the pop. and how testing including anti-body testing to date has missed so many.

Interesting piece about tautologies, just being picky about one point.
Though I am not sure you have made your point well.

The jump from B to C is not dependent on A. Indeed lockdown might* have been extremely effective in reducing covid deaths, while the jump from B to C remains legitimate.

* In fact all we could say for certain is lockdown might have been effective in delaying deaths - by 6 months or so in care homes**, by perhaps 2 years in other cases, and until the second and third wave for others.

** In countries like UK Excess deaths has been small negative for past month implying at least some of the covid victims might have been due to go soon (few care home patients stay there for 2 years).


I’m gonna go get the papers get the papers.


MD: I didn't make it clear in the post but the author used raw death counts, not excess deaths. From what I've seen so far, confirmed Covid deaths are not sufficient to explain all excess deaths but I've written here before that excess deaths require time to "mature". Also, good point about the (A) part of the setup; it just gives some context which should be stated separately.

Antonio Rinaldi

Every conspiracy theory is an example of P(A|D)=1 because P(A)=1.
(A=assumption, D=data)

Joshua Jendza

While this is not a tautology, it is an assumption without evidence.

"the advance towards herd immunity is rapid"

Herd immunity, depending on the disease, generally requires greater than 90% of the potential infection pool to be immune/resistant. More infectious diseases (which I would expect COVID-19 to be classified as) can require population level immunity of 99% or even higher.

Even most agressive estimates of infection rate for the US works out to a single digit percentage of the US population (which is the relevant pool). As of this writing, the CDC puts the US case rate at 1.5% after about 6 months. Even if we assume that the CDC numbers undercount exposures by a factor of 10 (meaning a true potentially immune pool of 15% today), we'd still need several years at the current run rate to reach 90% exposure. That does not meet my definition of "rapid"

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name is required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)

Kaiser Fung. Business analytics and data visualization expert. Author and Speaker.
Visit my website. Follow my Twitter. See my articles at Daily Beast, 538, HBR, Wired.

See my Youtube and Flickr.
Numbers Rule Your World:
Amazon - Barnes&Noble

Amazon - Barnes&Noble


  • only in Big Data

Next Events

Jan: 10 NYPL Data Science Careers Talk, New York, NY

Past Events

Aug: 15 NYPL Analytics Resume Review Workshop, New York, NY

Apr: 2 Data Visualization Seminar, Pasadena, CA

Mar: 30 ASA DataFest, New York, NY

See more here


R Fundamentals, Principal Analytics Prep

Numbersense: Statistical Reasoning in Practice, Principal Analytics Prep

Applied Analytics Frameworks & Methods, Columbia

The Art of Data Visualization, NYU

Signed copies at McNally-Jackson, NYC

Excerpts: Numbersense Ch. 1, 7, 8. NRYW

Junk Charts Blog

Link to junkcharts

Graphics design by Amanda Lee