« Santa is uber god, so says Venn | Main | How to mess up a bar chart »

Comments

Brandt

Isn't it easier to read, and just as informative, to simply put Paul between the others on the stacked chart? http://dl.dropbox.com/u/21362/two-or-three-party.jpg

Jon Peltier

I like the horizontal bar chart with labels on the bars. But I think it would be better keeping the bars grouped. Without the numeric labels, it's hard to tell that Obama's 51% beats Gingrich's 43%.

I like your use of a flow chart to track where Paul's votes come from.

Jon

It would be nice to see how an Obama vs Paul election would go too. That's probably a valuable piece of information.

John Roth

To me the truly interesting piece of information is that both results with Paul as a spoiler are almost exactly the same: two of them are identical and two differ by one point.

None of the versions make this obvious, although the flow chart at least makes it reasonably easy to find.

Tom Hopper

I am not a fan of the flow chart, as used here. The story of this graph is told almost entirely with numbers; take them away and the reader would learn nothing, except that some colored boxes point to others; the graphical elements serve only as highlighting for the numbers.

I think that a web plot, or bipartite graph, in which the width of ribbons connecting each side of the graph represent the number of votes transferring from candidate A to candidate B, would do a better job telling the story. Such graphs can be created in R with the "bipartite" package, and an example graph (much busier than your example) can be found here: http://www.oga-lab.net/RGM_results/bipartite/bipartite-package/bipartite-package_001_big.png

Another alternative might be to combine a cladogram-style decision tree with your bar graph of vote percentages. Something a bit like: http://www.scielo.br/img/revistas/babt/v52n6/a14fig02.gif. This might be the best option, as it would tell both stories in a single visual, and encourage thinking about the election results in detail.

Account Deleted

Adjusting the width of the arrows in the flow to show the relative sizes of the flows would make the chart clearer, and even better would be to adjust the sizes of the boxes too. (This would in effect give a bipartite graph as suggested by Tom Hopper.)

Antonio

Do horizontal bar charts violate self-sufficiency principle? IMO, it seems so. Indeed, I would not be so sad. I've never been sure that self-sufficiency should be always a virtue, and this case would be an example.

how to convert flv to mp4

Obama-Romney thing is really weird for me.
Hard to tell what i felt when Romney won here in Florida.
But i still think Obama is going to be re-elected.

The comments to this entry are closed.

BOOTCAMP SUMMER '19



Link to Principal Analytics Prep

See our curriculum, instructors. Apply.
Kaiser Fung. Business analytics and data visualization expert. Author and Speaker.
Visit my website. Follow my Twitter. See my articles at Daily Beast, 538, HBR.

See my Youtube and Flickr.

Book Blog



Link to junkcharts

Graphics design by Amanda Lee

The Read



Keep in Touch

follow me on Twitter

Residues