Interruption
False promises of equality and structure

Did days get longer in the last 30 years? Fast Company thinks so.

Craig N. sent us to this infographic from Fast Company about MTV's 30th anniversary, nominating it as the worst infographic ever.

Mtv_discs

Apply the self-sufficiency test to this chart. Wish away the printed data. Now, does the chart convey any message?  Where is the data embedded? Is it in the white dot, the black dot, the gold ring, the gold disc, the black ring, the eye-white? All of the above?

Now, do the same test on this chart (I removed the sales data, replacing it with years):

Mtv_square2

How would one compare the white to the orange? If one measures the lengths of the sides, the ratio of white to orange is about 1.32. If one compares areas of the squares, then the ratio is 1.73. Note that this requires the reader to see through the orange area to size up the area of the large white square. Alternatively, we can compute the ratio of the white area as observed to the orange square, and that ratio is 0.73.

The real ratio between 1980 and 2010 sales is given as 3.9/2.7 = 1.44. Given rounding errors, it seems like the designer may have used a ratio of lengths of the sides.

The problem is the same whether sides or areas are used. Can the reader figure out that the 1980 sales is about 40% higher than the 2010 sales?

I suspect that most of us react primarily to the visible areas, which means that we'd have gotten the direction of the change wrong, let alone the magnitude.

***

 

Mtv_racetrack Craig really dislikes this one. It's a variant of the racetrack chart. As any athlete knows, inner tracks are shorter than outer tracks. Could it be that days have gotten longer in the last 30 years? Apparently, the editors at Fast Company think so.

Comments

Cody L. Custis

The goal of the music video airtime graphic is to convey that MTV once focused on music videos, and now rarely shows them. A racetrack chart would work well for this, although this racetrack chart has problems.

I would have superimposed the bands on a clock, kept the colors the same between tracks, and put in a color for everything else MTV is showing (Jersey Shore, Teen Mom, Jersey Shore reruns, Teen Mom reruns, etc.).

Account Deleted

I tend to perceive the last chart like concentric pie charts, and I see the differences between angles rather than lenght. Their version is bad (why not two timelines?), but I'll try to remember it, it may be useful.

Another point: pie charts of the hours of a day never work. I tend to see a 12-hour clock, so that magenta slice means 3 hours, instead of 6.

Tom

I realize I'm 6 months late here, but the chart referred to in the headline is by far the best of the 3 MTV charts displayed in the post. Saying Fast Company thinks days got longer is like saying "Fast Company doesn't even know that big clocks tell time faster than small clocks!"

The comments to this entry are closed.