« A pie factory | Main | Light entertainment: Top Chef »

Comments

Bob

I agree, this chart is odd. But, just to be picky, the parallelograms do not change the total area of each segment, as long as the vertical distances are in proportion? Comparing the parallelograms to the rectangular regions that they "replace", each merely adds a triangular area to the top of the rectangle and removes an identical triangular area from the bottom. Or another way of putting it, area = base x perpendicular height.

Jon Peltier

"What's wrong with the standard stacked column?"

Bar charts, column charts, and line charts all suffer from the same issue. Though perfectly utilitarian, they are perceived as boring, and needing of enhancement. Hence 3D effects, shadows, color gradients, overlapping semi-transparent areas, and other funky bells and whistles, like the strange spacing effect in this chart.

William Ockham

It's supposed to look like a TV.

Kaiser

Bob: the areas would not be distorted only if all the parallellograms have parallel sides. But if so, then the designer would have failed to create space between the boxes on the right.

Hermus

Beyond the visual problems you've described, I have a problem with the whole premise of the data. Can you really claim a few giants are ruling when the top 5 brands have barely over half the market?

carlitos

Kaiser: I think Bob is right. The area of the parallelograms doesn't depend on the angle: for each connecting piece it will be the distance between the stacked columns times the market share (assuming the gap width is constant and the heights are the same for each category on both stacked bars, otherwise the connectors are not parallelograms). The area for each category in the composite chart (which I agree is odd) is just the total chart width times the height of each region (constant).

Kaiser

You guys are good! There is no actual distortion in area because the vertical sides are not altered. Thanks for the correction.

Dan

I imagine that perhaps they started off with a standard stacked column chart, but some editor complained that the different shades of pink/peach were two subtle to be differentiated visually, so the chart maker compromised by adding actual spaces between the areas... but only on one side...?

The comments to this entry are closed.

BOOTCAMP SUMMER '19



Link to Principal Analytics Prep

See our curriculum, instructors. Apply.
Kaiser Fung. Business analytics and data visualization expert. Author and Speaker.
Visit my website. Follow my Twitter. See my articles at Daily Beast, 538, HBR.

See my Youtube and Flickr.

Book Blog



Link to junkcharts

Graphics design by Amanda Lee

The Read



Keep in Touch

follow me on Twitter

Residues