« It's tiny | Main | Bound to extremes »

Comments

Yihui

Sure, a line chart is better than a bar chart on illustrating time-series data, especially when there is background grid.

Jorge Camoes

There is a nuance (oops!) in Godin's laws: they only apply to Powerpoint presentations, not to information display in general. (Uff!)

Seth Godin on graphs: not exactly a purple cow.

John S.

Jorge, why should putting a graph in a Powerpoint presentation make any diference? Most of us have to present our work to customers and peers in formal presentations. I follow similar principles in making graphs for published articles and for presentation slides. In keeping with the first point, I do tend to choose simpler graphics for presentation. But the rest of Godin's advice is pretty bad, even if it is just meant to apply to Powerpoints.

Consider "no barcharts". The graphic accompanying this article is a recent example of a barchart that I found interesting. Kaiser may be correct that a line chart is better suited to showing change over time, but can you imagine how terrible these data would look in a pie chart?

Personally I cringe every time I see some Congressman on C-SPAN standing in front of a big chart on an easel (perhaps it's just the memory of Ross Perot, who began the trend), but a graphic like the one in the Times article would certainly be appropriate in that setting. A pie chart just wouldn't work.

Jon Peltier

John -

It's not PowerPoint specifically, it's the target audience. Seth is a marketing guru, and he's talking about his guidelines for sharing data with nontechnical audiences. He seems to think oversimplification is a good practice, particularly when leading sheep.

I've just written my third post on the topic of Seth's charting philosophies:
On Seth Godin on Charts

Jorge Camoes

John, would you use sparklines in a Powerpoint presentation for a large audience? Probably not. The principles may be similar, but different resolutions and viewing conditions mean that you need to choose your charts carefully.

Andreas Lipphardt

In chart design it’s good to make things simple, but you certainly should avoid oversimplification.

As Einstein said: "Things should be made as simple as possible, but not any simpler"

Effective chart design follows a simple and robust chart type selection process

  1. Determine the relationship you want to display
  2. Determine if you want to emphasize individual values or the overall pattern
  3. Determine the chart type The set of available chart types certainly includes the bar chart, just use the bar chart in the appropriated business context.

More on Chart Rules, As Simple as Possible, But Not Any Simpler!

The comments to this entry are closed.

Kaiser Fung. Business analytics and data visualization expert. Author and Speaker.
Visit my website. Follow my Twitter. See my articles at Daily Beast, 538, HBR.

See my Youtube and Flickr.

Book Blog



Link to junkcharts

Graphics design by Amanda Lee

The Read



Keep in Touch

follow me on Twitter

Residues