« Close races | Main | Light enertainment: raining colors »


Michal Migurski


For all his excellent work, Ed Tufte seems blind to the information graphic as interface, catalog, or browsing mechanism. His iPhone critique video was a prime example of this misunderstanding, with his suggestion of a static UI to replace a supple, reactive, tactile, and temporal one.


I hadn't heard about the dichotomoy between "statistical graphic" and "information graphic" before, I've beeen calling them both "information graphic". Where did you get this distinction?


Does anyone think the difference between being ranked 1 and 2 is more significant than the difference between being ranked 71 and 72?

If so would this justify the use of a distorted scale? What type of distorted scale - perhaps a log scale?


Derek: It's a bit of wordsmithing here. In my view, there is nothing "statistical" about this chart. All the data is being presented; there is no smoothing, averaging, or other techniques used to separate signal from noise.


Gelman highlighted another one of these "catalog" graphics by the same team


I understand there is nothing statistical about that graph, but why is there nothing "info" about statistical graphs?


Not sure if infographics is the right word but there needs to be a distinction between statistical graphics and the rest which amounts to visualization, EDA or similar.


I agree with Michael, log scale would work much better. Problem is most of the public don't understand log scales, they aren't even used for share prices over time.

Jon Peltier

Derek -

In Flowing Data, Nathan has distinguished statistical from information graphics as follows:

statistical visualization - viz for the sole purpose of analysis e.g. graphics in R

infographics - graphics not quite for data e.g. graphics in the news

(See comment to this post.)

Most graphics fall between the two extremes.

The comments to this entry are closed.


Link to Principal Analytics Prep

See our curriculum, instructors. Apply.
Kaiser Fung. Business analytics and data visualization expert. Author and Speaker.
Visit my website. Follow my Twitter. See my articles at Daily Beast, 538, HBR.

See my Youtube and Flickr.

Book Blog

Link to junkcharts

Graphics design by Amanda Lee

The Read

Keep in Touch

follow me on Twitter