Whither complexity?
Graphs as catalogs

Close races

Nyt_citylimits1 Perhaps harkening to the close race between Obama and Clinton, the designer chose to illustrate this with what we have called the "racetrack" graph.  We have previously discussed the problems here and here.

Nyt_citylimits2 In this rendition, a pie chart was divided into three race tracks with "cities" getting the inside track and "rural/small cities" getting the outside track.  (As the Clinton supporters might say, elitism was in the air.)  There were two great choices: the courage to not print the data and let the chart speak for itself, and the wisdom to white out the votes for "others".

Nevertheless, as we discussed before, the data is coded into the angles rather than the lengths of the strips, which presents a real problem in comparing vote shares.  For example, try figuring out if there were more Obama supporters in rural Tennessee than there were Clinton supporters in cities in Tennessee (bottom right).

Nyt_citylimits3 Also note where the white "others" space were, and the impossibliity of comparing them.

The arrangement for Wisconsin, meanwhile, posed a challenge for anyone who wanted to estimate how many rural Wisconsin voters went for "others".


In the junkart version, we go with the two-sided bar chart, typically found in population pyramids.  The information presented jumps out at you.

Redo_citylimits3 This chart is essentially the same as the racetrack; one just needs to straighten out the strips from the original chart, and pull the Clinton ones clockwise, and Obama ones anti-clockwise.



Reference: some recent issue of New York Times magazine.

Comments

Ken

Plotting the margins would seem even better, say Clinton margin +ve on right hand side and Obama on left. This would allow quick identification of who was more popular.

Jon Peltier

The only piece of chart junk I might add to your two sided bar charts is vertical gridlines at ±50%.

If you used a one-sided clustered bar chart, you could more readily compare the lengths of the Clinton and Obama bars. A little experimentation shows that this helps for comparisons where the two candidates are close (Wisconsin), but is completely worthless when they are far apart (Tennessee).

I've described my charting attempts here:
http://peltiertech.com/WordPress/2008/06/22/close-racesclose-races/

Jon Peltier

That URL came out wrong in my post. It should be:

http://peltiertech.com/WordPress/2008/06/22/close-races/.

derek

One of my favorite graph types :-)

I'd only make one comment, which is that I think the cyan is a little too light to easily see, and perhaps I'd prefer a blue or magenta bar instead.

Or, since the bars are physically separate, why not have them be the same color and just label the sides "Clinton" and "Obama"? Different colors could then be used for some other dimension of information, if there was one.

Markus Koljonen

I'd also consider adding the magical 50% treshold (Could it be a background color instead of a vertical line?) as it is a visual piece of information that is lost in the transfer - as is the "others" white space, even with its failures.

derek

If you want the 50% line so much, and also miss the "Others", it's probably time to give up on the two-sided bar graph altogether, and go back to the 100% stacked bar graph. That's my usual default for three series that add up to 100%, of which two far outweigh the third.

Kaiser

Great comments all! Derek's version is a nice alternative. There really is no need for any colors at all; I just need to put Obama and Clinton on the axis.

derek

What might be a nice bit of extra value would be if we knew the numbers of voters in the cities, suburbs, and rures in WI and TN. Making the bar graphs into matrix graphs would add information about the urbanization of the two states, and the areas of the bars would sum to tell you who won the overall primary (at the moment you can't see who won in Tennessee because that's lost in the breakdown).

Jon Peltier

I've made some small changes and additions in a follow-up:
http://peltiertech.com/WordPress/2008/06/24/close-races-2/

luke54

Hey Guys,want to Know more about charts? If yes then just follow the link visifire an amazing charting component powered by silverlight

Qlikview Training Classes Online

cool

The comments to this entry are closed.