« An embarrassment | Main | Progress and retrogress »


Oskar Shapley

The vertical graphs is more readable. We are talking about a 'level' variable.


There is something I don't like about this representation.

This representation assumes, or at least suggests, that at the finest level there is no group with a highest literacy rate than the males from Cuautitlan, Mexico and none with a lower rate than the females from Metlatonoc, Guerrero.

What if that weren't the case? what if there was a group with a higher literacy rate than the one shown on the chart, although their municipality or province would have a lower score than Cuautitlan or Mexico? or conversely, what if there was a group with a lower score than 20 even though their municipality or province did better than Metlatonoc or Guerrero? in that case the graph wouldn't work or at least it would be misleading. that's only coincidence that the subsets with extreme values happen to be part of subsets with extreme values at a higher level.


I get the impression that this representation only sets out to illustrate how extreme the disparity is, not to conclusively rule on the absolute extrema. It works for me. Once I got what was going on, I actually prefer the original chart; I found the graphical representation with shading "fanning out" to connect the subsets helped me to visually group the extrema more easily than the junkchart version. Looking only at the municipality column, Acapulco and Metlatonoc clearly belong in the same grouping. The junkchart version requires me to look up to origination point of the connecting lines in the Province row to make the same association. My only change to the original would be to eliminate the horizontal lines connecting the successive subsets, since it is redundant with the shaded areas almost to the point of losing clarity.

The comments to this entry are closed.


Link to Principal Analytics Prep

See our curriculum, instructors. Apply.
Kaiser Fung. Business analytics and data visualization expert. Author and Speaker.
Visit my website. Follow my Twitter. See my articles at Daily Beast, 538, HBR.

See my Youtube and Flickr.

Book Blog

Link to junkcharts

Graphics design by Amanda Lee

The Read

Keep in Touch

follow me on Twitter