Calming the rip tide
Flight of fancy

Poll numbers

The Political Arithmetik blog has great graphics pertaining to, surprise surprise, political matters.  I really like the ones portraying Presidential approval ratings. 

Bushfullterm20061022This chart plots all the different polls (grey dots) at once; the blue line is the estimated approval rate over time while the scatter of grey dots provides an estimate of the reliability of the blue line. 

Different polls are different random samples of the population.  Random sampling is not fool-proof; any one sample has a chance, albeit small, to poorly represent the population.  That's why the dots add greatly to the chart.

ApprovalatmidtermDerek pointed me to a different chart, a simple dot plot that shows Bush's 2006 mid-term approval rate was the 2nd worst since 1946.  To paraphrase him, this is a scenario in which the chart does not add much because the underlying data is a simple ranked list.

He also suggested differentiating the 2nd term presidents from the one-termers. 

Shown below is another view of the data,  emphasizing the time dimension.  The linked dots represent two-term presidents.  The gridlines delineate the minimum, average and maximum approval ratings over time.  Another line shows Bush's 2006 approval rating, which is the 2nd worst since 1946.   Redo_approvalrate

Lots of other great charts at this blog.  Check them out.

 

Comments

FaithfulWeb

The third chart could use red and blue to indicate whether the president was a Republican or a Democrat.

Goldfish

Isn't it remarkable also that he has both the second-lowest and the second-highest approval rates??

ZBicyclist

Truman is a two-term president and Lyndon Johnson is a one-term president?
Better to say "dots connect observations in which the president is the same".

Kaiser

In most cases, isn't it the case that if a President had two mid-term ratings, he would have had two terms?

Political history is definitely not my forte. So I stand corrected.

Xris (Flatbush Gardener)

I find the tick-marks associated with the years confusing; years are not points on a line. I'm guessing that it marks January 1st for each year?

Placing the year labels between the tick-marks would be clearer.

Jon Peltier

Xris -

The years are categories along the categorical X axis (along with the labels indicating current president).

If you want a precise date, the relevant mid-term approval rating is that measured just before the elections in early November.

The comments to this entry are closed.