« Higher, higher and higher | Main | Arming the competition »

Comments

Tal Rotbart

I love this diagram, but I have two small points to make:

I'm missing a sense of the direction for the flow. I know that for most of the western world the left-to-right flow is assumed and obvious. But I come from a right-to-left language and an arrow head on the right-most ends of the flow would have helped me quite a bit.
My second point is just the simple "Rejected energy" label which in the original graph was "Conversion losses", which was more accurate and had a stronger message.

All in all, an excellent graph.

Kaiser

Tal - great comment

One nice feature of this chart is that it is symmetric in the sense that if I want to know what were the sources of the "useful energy", I could trace this from right to left

Your point about the cultural preference of reading from left to right versus right to left is still valid. One can ask why one doesn't put the energy sources on the right and the uses on the left!

Robert Kosara

"As it stands, this chart murmurs but does not opine."

Interesting point! I guess that makes it a visualization, rather than an information graphic. The visualization (IMHO) should not bias the view in any way, but leave drawing the conclusions to the viewer. An information graphic is usually drawn to make a point, and will therefore stress certain things more. Of course, none of them are completely unbiased, but at least the visualization will try to as much as possible.

I personally prefer the unbiased view, because it makes the things I find much more impressive than knowing that the data has been predigested and the graphic is just a colorful way of shoving the conclusion into my face.

Roger Daventry

Somewhat like a railway system with platforms to the traintracks of energy use. Quite a tangle. Sad for me is that the figures do not add up and I wonder where the lost bits are or is it the overspend of 'non fuel'?
I feel that the comparisons perhaps do not need so much detail. The detail can be in the individual tracks. Perhaps it is better to have sub plot visuals with the comparison giving the message required for discussion?

The comments to this entry are closed.

BOOTCAMP SUMMER '19



Link to Principal Analytics Prep

See our curriculum, instructors. Apply.
Kaiser Fung. Business analytics and data visualization expert. Author and Speaker.
Visit my website. Follow my Twitter. See my articles at Daily Beast, 538, HBR.

See my Youtube and Flickr.

Book Blog



Link to junkcharts

Graphics design by Amanda Lee

The Read



Keep in Touch

follow me on Twitter

Residues