« Light entertainment: Behold the 10 percent change! | Main | Free NYU session on data visualization »

Comments

Andy

The number of users is not a log scale on the original figure

Andrew Gelman

Kaiser:

Your graph is, from the statistical perspective, a zillion times better than what was published. On the other hand, unusual images can get attention. Recall the famous/notorious clock plot from Florence Nightingale. This is why I've moved to the idea of accepting both styles. Maybe Technology Review could feature their arty graph, but then when the reader clicks on it, they go straight to your informative graph. And then another click could go to a spreadsheet with the raw data (and as much metadata as needed).

P.S. On the details, I think your graph could be better. I'd like to see labels on all the points; one option would be to put the y-axis on a log scale so it will all be more readable. Also, then the straight lines on log scale will correspond to exponential growth, which might be more realistic than linear for most of the data. You could also play around with having the x-axis be absolute time rather than relative time, so that we could see when each platform started.

Chris Moore

I don't think that the tiltedness in itself is a big problem. That is, I think that human beings are well enough able to parse the isometric layout for it to be a legit way to lay out the information, and it's easy enough on the eye. If your graph were laid out in the isometric layout, then there'd be no problem at all.

I'm more troubled about the bottom graphs. The line graph would be absolutely fine if the labels weren't arranged to be perpendicular to the page. As it’s done here, you’re encouraged to interpret the lines as coming out of the graph as well, and then you’ve lost your ability to interpret the data.

The stacked column chart is…a bit odd. Again, there’s nothing wrong with presenting the data this way, in my view, but there are a few simple and obvious things that could be done to make it easier to follow.

Anyway, my point is this – if the chart is essentially good, then the isometry shouldn’t be a problem. There are a few easy-to-fix data visualisation errors and some basic execution errors here that make the whole thing a bit of a chore to look at. But I’ve got to say that I would enjoy looking at this if the execution were better.

Kaiser

Andy: You're right. I was confused by how far apart the lower points
were on the chart (but of course, the locations of the icons don't
mean anything).

Andrew: There is something to your tradeoff thesis but I wouldn't use
it the way you are proposing. I agree it is great to offer up an
aggregated chart and then allow readers to click through for details.
But not two charts showing essentially the same thing.

Yes, the absolute time chart is interesting, so is plotting the
trajectory rather than just the peak of each curve. I suspect, though,
that the designer started with the full trajectories and decided to
simplify to just the peak. (Those charts are widely available.) So the
line to the origin is just a guide to show the average growth rate.
Exponential growth is likely a better approximation to the truth.

Chris: Interesting that you like isometric but yes, the bottom two
charts are even more unnecessarily tilted than the top one.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Marketing analytics and data visualization expert. Author and Speaker. Currently at Vimeo and NYU. See my full bio.

Book Blog



Link to junkcharts

Graphics design by Amanda Lee

The Read



Good Books

Keep in Touch

follow me on Twitter

Residues