« No sorting and lack of structure undermine a chart | Main | Nice example of histograms »

Comments

Jamie

Great use of a dot plot. Nicely done.
Allows easy comparison between majors and provinces at the same time.

Darin Myers

This dot plot is definitely an improvement over the petal design in facilitating understanding. As you relate, it is easy to see that Quebec is the least costly in nearly every major. Visual Arts is the only major where they come in 2nd.

Considering the rest of the data, another interesting story that could be told, simply by coloring another set of dots, is that Ontario's costs are near the top in every major, and ranks as the most costly in all but three. It appears, from this perspective, that Ontario may have more reason to protest than Quebec.

Finally, Saskatchewan must have one incredible Dentistry program to warrant the highest cost in the Nation.

Sebastian Villarreal

One should almost always avoid using circles to display data. Here are a few reasons why (anti-circle rant follows):
1) Circles are limiting. A good chart should allow the viewer to work with the data. That is, the reader should be able to use a ruler/finger/eye/folded piece of paper to measure the screen or printout and make calculations. It's fairly easy to eyeball or measure the difference in height between two histograms, for example. Comparing the area of two circles is much harder.
2) The is no "standard" for circles. Sure, we *expect* that the area of a circle represents the quantity of interest, but are we really sure? There are definitely plots out there where the radius represents the quantity of interest. This is important because...
3) Areas are misleading. Our eyes are good at eyeballing lengths, not areas. So we will "naturally" compare the diameters of two circles, even if the quantity of interest is the area. This means the impact of the chart will be way way off, because of the squared relationship. Circles will minimize the apparent difference in quantities for this reason.

So, in general: avoid plots where there is a non linear relationship between some aspect of the plot and the quantity of interest. If one must use areas, then use squares, not circles, so that the user can more easily compare different elements of the plot.

Ok, end of rant.

BrousseLaine

Even though the dot plot is a major improvement over the flower graph, it is still a reminder that any graph can be deficient with incomplete data.

In this case, it miserably fails to take into account the much higher tax rate in Qu├ębec, where money is used for getting those low tuition fees.

So, go on. Raise your taxes and lower your tuitions, then we'll compare apples with apples.

John

Nice post. However, the proposed tuition increase is not 10%. It is an additional $325 (give or take, the raise in under negotiation) per year, for each of the next five years. Total increase = 75%.

Jay

Hi - Late post but... Went to B-school in Canada. We have many churn undergrad programs that save actual graduates tuition on the backs of the half to two thirds of entrants who flunk out by junior/senior year. It is my understanding the U.S. schools often promote study of diverse topics for these years, potentially acclimating students for the remaining two years of Organizational Behaviour and Statistics (etc.) that could drive early drop-outs.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Marketing analytics and data visualization expert. Author and Speaker. Currently at Vimeo and NYU. See my full bio.

Book Blog



Link to junkcharts

Graphics design by Amanda Lee

The Read



Good Books

Keep in Touch

follow me on Twitter

Residues